Choosing the right baseball glove can improve your game and make every catch smoother. Whether you're an infielder, outfielder, pitcher, or recreational player, this guide breaks down the top 5 gloves based on material, fit, durability, and position-specific features. Here's a quick summary:
- Wilson A2000: Durable Pro Stock leather with lightweight SuperSkin. Great for all positions.
- Rawlings Heart of the Hide: Premium steerhide leather. Trusted by MLB players, ideal for outfielders.
- Mizuno Pro Select: US Steerhide leather with position-specific pocket designs. Perfect for serious players.
- Nokona Walnut Series: American-made Walnut Crunch™ leather. Versatile and game-ready.
- Rawlings Player Preferred: Full-grain leather at an affordable price. Best for recreational use.
Quick Comparison
| Glove | Material | Best For | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wilson A2000 | Pro Stock leather, SuperSkin | All positions | $$$ |
| Rawlings Heart of the Hide | Premium steerhide | Outfielders | $$$ |
| Mizuno Pro Select | US Steerhide | Infield/Outfield | $$$ |
| Nokona Walnut Series | Walnut Crunch leather | Versatile | $$$$ |
| Rawlings Player Preferred | Full-grain leather | Recreational | $ |
Each glove offers unique advantages tailored to specific player needs. Read on to find the perfect fit for your game and tips to maintain your glove for years to come.
The TOP 5 Baseball Gloves In My Collection
How to Choose a Baseball Glove
When picking a baseball glove, focus on these key factors to find the right fit for your needs.
Position-Specific Sizing
The size of your glove depends on your position and age. For adult infielders, gloves between 11.25 and 12.25 inches provide the best control and reach. Outfielders typically go for larger gloves, around 12.5 to 12.75 inches, to cover more ground. Here's a quick size guide for younger players:
| Position | Age Group | Recommended Size |
|---|---|---|
| Infield | 8–10 years | 10.75–11.5 inches |
| Infield | 11–12 years | 11–11.75 inches |
| Outfield | 11–12 years | 11.75–12.5 inches |
| Pitcher | 11–12 years | 11.5–12.5 inches |
Leather Quality
The type of leather plays a big role in performance and durability. Here's a breakdown of popular options:
- Cowhide: Breaks in quickly, making it a good choice for youth players.
- Steerhide: Offers excellent durability but requires a longer break-in period; ideal for high school and college players.
- Kip Leather: Lighter than steerhide with good durability; often used by college and pro players.
- Japanese Kip: Known for its premium quality and balanced weight, perfect for elite players.
Web Patterns
The web pattern impacts pocket depth and ball transfer. Choose a design based on your position:
- I-Web: Best for infielders needing quick transitions and clear ball visibility.
- H-Web: Works well for both infielders and outfielders.
- Basket Web: Great for pitchers and outfielders; provides a deep pocket.
- Trapeze Web: Designed for outfielders seeking extra support.
Fit and Comfort
Your glove should feel snug but not restrictive, allowing natural hand movement and control.
"A smaller glove will be easier for a young player." - Wilson Sporting Goods
Budget
High-quality leather gloves come with a higher price tag but last longer. Think about how often you play when setting your budget.
1. Wilson A2000
Material Quality
The Wilson A2000 is made with American Pro Stock Steerhide leather, known for its toughness and long-lasting performance. This leather strikes the perfect mix of softness and flexibility, helping players shape a reliable pocket. Shigeaki Aso, Wilson's Master Glove Craftsman, explains:
"Leather is so important. A really important thing is a certain level of softness is needed. A certain level of stretchiness is needed. Our Pro Stock leather is perfect for that".
Some models in the A2000 series use SuperSkin, a lightweight synthetic material that's twice as strong as leather but half the weight. MLB star Mookie Betts shares his thoughts on this feature:
"It's just light. When it rains, it doesn't sit in the leather. I think the most important thing for me is just that it doesn't get heavy. Standing out in the outfield, when you're running, you have a nice light glove on".
Durability
The A2000 stands out for its lasting performance, thanks to its high-quality materials. SuperSkin models are particularly easy to maintain. Ryan Smith, Wilson’s Senior Glove Designer, explains:
"A damp rag with water is all you need to keep SuperSkin in the best shape possible. Just wipe it off and then let it dry. It is really a maintenance-free material".
Position Suitability
The A2000 series is designed with specific positions in mind, offering options for every spot on the field. For example, the 1786 pattern, an 11.5-inch model, is a favorite among middle infielders due to its quick transfer capabilities. Players can pick the model that best fits their needs for optimal performance.
2. Rawlings Heart of the Hide
Material Quality
The Rawlings Heart of the Hide gloves are crafted from the top 5% of steerhide, ensuring excellent performance on the field. Inside, a deer-tanned cowhide lining enhances comfort, while a thermo-formed, moisture-wicking wrist liner keeps the glove secure and dry. Some models also feature synthetic materials like Pro-Mesh and Hyper Shell, which add performance benefits and reduce weight. To boost durability, the gloves are reinforced with Tennessee Tanning rawhide laces.
Durability
Introduced in the 1960s, the Heart of the Hide series quickly became known for its high-quality leather and long-lasting performance. The natural firmness of the steerhide helps the glove maintain its shape, even with heavy use. Many players value these gloves so much that they pass them down to the next generation.
Position Suitability
Thanks to their sturdy design, Heart of the Hide gloves are built to meet the needs of players in various positions. The lineup includes options for every role, from 11.25-inch gloves for infielders to 13-inch models for outfielders and first basemen. Catchers can choose from six mitt options, all featuring Dual Core technology for position-specific palm padding that helps with break-in. With over half of MLB players using Rawlings gloves, the Heart of the Hide series clearly stands out as a trusted choice for professional-level performance.
3. Mizuno Pro Select
Material Quality
The Mizuno Pro Select is crafted from high-quality US Steerhide leather, offering durability and a professional feel. It includes Steersoft Elite palm liners for added comfort and padded thumb slots for extra protection. Together, these features create a glove that holds its shape and delivers a reliable performance. The design is tailored for specific positions, ensuring players get the best fit and functionality.
"Pro Select combines Mizuno's rich glove heritage with advanced glove scans of hundreds of professionals to create pocket designs tailored specifically to each position and how players prefer to break-in their glove." - Mizuno USA
Position Suitability
What sets the Mizuno Pro Select apart is its position-specific design, offering three pocket depths to cater to different player needs:
- Shallow pockets: Ideal for middle infielders who need quick ball transfers.
- Regular pockets: A versatile option suitable for various positions.
- Deep pockets: Designed for shortstops and third basemen.
Each glove is built with patterns that simplify the break-in process while maintaining its shape. Mizuno uses advanced scanning technology to ensure every model aligns with the demands of specific positions.
Durability
Made with premium Steerhide leather, these gloves are built to last. However, some players mention that the leather's stiffness makes the break-in period longer. The professional-grade lacing ensures the glove can handle regular, intense use without compromising performance.
Price Range
The Mizuno Pro Select series falls into the premium category of baseball gloves. Its high-quality materials and position-specific design come at a higher price point, making it a preferred choice for serious players seeking durability and top-tier performance.
sbb-itb-d0a8c9d
4. Nokona Walnut Series
Material Quality
The Nokona Walnut Series is crafted from Walnut Crunch™ leather, a full-grain steer hide that undergoes a detailed tanning process. During the "crust" stage, the leather is treated with oils and waxes, compressed under high pressure, and dyed with aniline colors. This process gives the glove its signature "crunch" texture and feel, ensuring both quality and performance.
Durability
This glove is built to last. Even after three years of use, Joseph Newbern's Nokona W-1175 glove showed only minor lacing issues and a few scuffs, proving its resilience over time.
"This is a high quality, good looking, workhorse of a glove. It wasn't difficult to break in and holds up very well. Good heavy leather, great design and very well constructed."
– Adam, Nokona Ballgloves Customer
Position Suitability
The Walnut Series is designed to suit a variety of field positions. With different web styles and sizes, it's a solid choice for utility players. High school pitcher Logan Stanton used his glove for pitching, second base, and outfield over two years, showcasing its all-around flexibility.
Price Range
Priced at around $400, the Walnut Series includes a one-year warranty.
"This glove is absolutely worth the price. Treat it well and don't take any shortcuts in breaking it in and it will take care of you for a very long time."
– sunalsorises, Nokona Ballgloves Customer
5. Rawlings Player Preferred
Material Quality
The Rawlings Player Preferred glove is made from full-grain, oiled leather. Its all-leather laces are interwoven to add strength and help the glove maintain its shape over time.
Position Suitability
This glove series offers various sizes to suit different players and positions. Designed for recreational baseball and softball, the Player Preferred gloves fit players at multiple skill levels and positions.
| Position | Adult Size (12+ years) |
|---|---|
| Infield | 11.25" – 12" |
| Outfield | 12" – 12.75" |
| First Base | 12" – 13" |
For younger players (ages 7–12), the infield sizes range from 10.25" to 11.5", while the outfield sizes go from 11.5" to 12.25".
Durability
This glove stands out for its durability during regular use. Many players report long-lasting performance, with one reviewer mentioning they only needed minor lacing adjustments after eight years of play. That kind of longevity makes it a dependable option.
Price Range
Priced at $59.95 (down from $74.95), the Player Preferred glove offers solid construction at a reasonable cost. It holds a 5-star customer rating.
"This is an excellent ball glove that doesn't break the bank!"
With its durable materials and budget-friendly price, this glove is a go-to choice for players who want reliable performance without overspending.
Glove Features at a Glance
Here's a breakdown of how some of the top baseball gloves stack up in terms of materials, key features, and position suitability. The table below highlights the main specifications, followed by a closer look at how these aspects impact performance on the field.
| Feature | Wilson A2000 | Rawlings Heart of the Hide | Mizuno Pro Select | Nokona Walnut Series | Rawlings Player Preferred |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Pro Stock leather with SuperSkin | Premium steerhide leather | Full-grain pigskin leather | Premium American leather | Full-grain leather |
| Best Position | All positions | Outfield | All positions | Infield | Recreational/All positions |
| Key Technology | SuperSkin technology | - | Patented heel flex technology | - | Pro-H web design |
| Notable Features | ProLux leather palm lining | Perfect padding for high catches | Enhanced closure and smooth operation | Game-ready out of the box | Quality construction and versatile design |
| Pros | Comfortable feel and advanced features | Durable, MLB-recommended | Soft feel and easy closure | Ready-to-play with premium quality | Adjustable, comfortable, and affordable |
| Cons | Higher price point | Expensive | - | Premium pricing | Durability may be an issue |
The Wilson A2000 stands out with its moisture-resistant SuperSkin for added durability and control. Mizuno Pro Select’s smooth closure system also enhances control, giving players an edge on the field. The Nokona Walnut Series is ready for action straight out of the box, while the Rawlings Player Preferred offers solid construction at a more accessible price.
"These gloves represent top-tier performance and quality".
When choosing a glove, focus on the materials, design, and features that align with your position and style of play. The right glove can make all the difference in your on-field performance.
How to Care for Your Baseball Glove
Taking care of your glove is key to keeping it in top shape and ensuring it lasts for years. Here's a guide to help you maintain your glove properly.
Breaking In Your New Glove
Breaking in your glove the right way can make a big difference in how it performs on the field.
"The priority should be softening up [the glove] in the right spots. The worst thing that can happen is that you break it in so it's soft and usable, but you're not happy with the way that you're receiving the ball or the way that it feels in your hand".
How to Break It In:
- Play catch regularly to naturally form the glove.
- Bend key areas and shape the pocket with a baseball and rubber bands.
- Use a wooden mallet to soften the pocket.
What to Avoid:
"If you got a nice, new leather jacket, you wouldn't put it in the oven. You're not going to drench your leather coat or briefcase in water. You don't want to do that with your glove, either".
Avoid microwaving, baking, or leaving your glove in hot environments like a car.
Cleaning and Maintenance
Regular cleaning and maintenance can help extend the life of your glove. Here's a simple guide:
| Maintenance Task | How to Do It | How Often |
|---|---|---|
| Basic Cleaning | Use a soft-bristle brush or damp cloth | After each use |
| Deep Cleaning | Apply a leather-safe cleaner with a soft cloth | Monthly |
| Conditioning | Use leather conditioner sparingly | Every 2–3 months |
| Lace Tightening | Check and adjust laces | Monthly |
| Pocket Reshaping | Store with a ball in the pocket | Ongoing |
After cleaning, proper storage is just as important to keep your glove in good condition.
Proper Storage
Follow these storage tips to maintain your glove's shape and quality:
- Keep a baseball in the pocket to preserve its shape.
- Store it in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight.
- Avoid leaving it in equipment bags for long periods.
- Use a clean, absorbent rag to remove moisture.
- Consider a glove wrap for transport.
- For extra protection, use a glove guardian (available for $40 at BaseballExpress.com).
Conditioning Tips
Conditioning helps keep the leather flexible and durable. Use glove oil sparingly and only on dry areas.
"Oiling a baseball glove allows an easier break-in and helps maintain the leather's durability and flexibility. No one wants their expensive Wilson or Rawlings baseball glove to last only several games!"
Some recommended products include Rawlings Gold Glove Butter ($8) and other leather-safe cleaners specifically made for baseball gloves.
Choosing the Right Baseball Glove
Finding the right baseball glove comes down to your position, skill level, and budget. Here's a quick guide to help you make the best choice, along with a reminder that proper care will keep your glove in top shape for years to come.
For infielders, the Wilson A2000 and Nokona Walnut Series stand out with shallow pockets for quick ball transfers. The Mizuno Pro Select offers flexibility with pocket depths tailored to specific positions.
Outfielders should consider the Rawlings Heart of the Hide, known for its high-quality leather and deep pocket - perfect for catching fly balls. Its steerhide leather construction is a favorite among pros.
If you're a recreational player looking for durability without breaking the bank, the Rawlings Player Preferred is a solid option. Its full-grain leather build provides reliability and versatility.
| Position | Recommended Glove | Key Feature |
|---|---|---|
| Infield | Wilson A2000 | Quick ball transfer |
| Outfield | Rawlings Heart of the Hide | Deep pocket for fly balls |
| Recreational Use | Rawlings Player Preferred | Durable and versatile |
For experienced players, the Wilson A2000 offers moisture-resistant SuperSkin technology and Pro Stock leather for durability and performance. Meanwhile, the Mizuno Pro Select uses full-grain pigskin leather, combining softness with long-lasting quality.
Taking care of your glove is just as important as choosing the right one. Regular maintenance will ensure your glove stays a dependable part of your gear season after season.